Reading about David's death at age 69 I can't help but think of my own father's death in '69 when we, my mother (52 at the time) and I, considered him gone too soon, when I was only 13 and he two days short of 71. I was the child that had to make up for all those killed during the Holocaust and my father asked me not to forget his story, history.
I promised him I would not, and up to today I consider his wish a command (I'm working on it Dad).
What story exactly? His story is my story, our history, my past and present and yes, my future. Yet, I have always felt more comfortable making visible the stories of others (as a designer for multicultural theater) than sharing my family's.
A visit around 1980 with a woman who practiced "automatic handwriting" helped me with my first attempts to grasp the extend of the influence of early loss of my father on my life. While automatic handwriting did open the gate, started the flow, I only shared my poetry. I did not think I could write worth while full sentences.
It wasn't until the loss of our baby daughter Ariane Eira in 1993, that I really started writing about my own loss and later in response to other people's losses. My husband called me the Ann Landers of Grief.
I don't know how I could have survived without writing down my feelings, or rather the translation in words of sensations. Writing about a baby's death the first as last question that remains unanswered even if the clinical reason for the demise is clear, is Why?
My father was an artist the last twenty years of his life. He painted and created objects in clay. One of his sculptures shows a man addressing G.d in despair, asking Why? Why hast thou forsaken me?
Writing about loss gives us besides a place to unload, to try and make sense, or to try and accept, a gauge to measure our development in the mourning process. Acknowledging our own or an other person's loss is never futile, it's all about remembering, paying respect, offering condolences. Remembering a person on the page is of great importance to those who are left behind.
When someone I've known, someone dear to my heart has died, I write down her name, cluster in Gabriele Rico's fashion around the name, bringing to the surface memories, deeper and further from the present time, I cluster about moments between back when and right now until a mental shift gives me the sentence that makes up the essence of what was or is most important about my relationship with the deceased.
I write letters to those who remain, or publish a blog post and when appropriate I send the poem Claribel Alegria wrote after her husband had died. Her books is among those that make me believe writing is a Creative Act of Healing.
Salí a buscarte
Salí a buscarte
atravesé valles
y montañas
surqué mares lejanos
le pregunté a las nubes
y al viento
inútil todo
inútil
dentro de mí estabas.
Searching for You
I went out searching for you
crossing valleys
and mountains
ploughing distant seas
asking of the clouds
and the wind your whereabouts
it was all useless
useless
you were within me.
Claribel Alegría
from Sorrow
Curbstone Press 1999
How do you find solace? Do you write about your own or other people's losses?
This work (prose) by Judith van Praag is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivs 3.0 Unported License


14 comments:
Beautiful and filled with such depth that one feels the loss of the person's loved one.
The thoughts of my dear friend is always with me and I find myself saying his name now and again......
Dear Savy, Thank you for your response. I'm sorry for your loss. By saying the name of a lost loved one, he or she is never forgotten.
Writing about loss with a "loved" one can be cathartic. I agree with you too. Writing about the loss it helpful.
I have one blog that is totally private and it's my place to write my anger, frustration and a whole lot more.
Dear Ciss B,
The way I read the first part of your response one can write with another person about a loss, or direct one's writing at the person who is no longer here —in the flesh— so to speak.
Would you mind sharing what it is about writing in the blog format that makes you want to trust your inner thoughts to a platform that is made for sharing, rather than just using a word processing document and storing your material on your computer?
I find solace through sharing with others, when I can help someone else through their grief, and when I can see beyond my immediate grief to a larger meaning, pattern, or history. I do write about loss, and other people's, too. In fiction more now than before. I get tired of my own voice and channel it into tactile things.
Thank you, Judith. This is a beautiful post.
Thanks for sharing, Judith. With a grief-related WIP, I can appreciate the hesitation to explore, and the relief once you do.
Just last week I was sorry to miss a series of Litchats on Twitter about writing about grief (you can see all the transcripts here: http://litchat.net/2010/08/09/gripping-grief/)...mainly about creating grief in the lives of fictional characters, but of course drawing on real grief experiences too.
I really connected with your post, as someone who lost a mother at age 17. I channeled much of my grief through poetry, though interestingly, my journal entries decreased significantly.
Writing truly is a wonderful way to heal the soul.
I spent the first half of my adult life writing newspaper features about entertainers, history, parenting..pretty much every topic. In those features there was never me. I had always wanted to write a book. It started when I was 9 and hid in my closet with a flashlight and read most of most nights. The first book I wrote was of the murder of my young brother. It did help bring me out of a darkness. As I am about to share the story with the world I feel a nakedness. The book is full of my secrets.
Now that it is complete I am writing the story of my husband's oldest son who died of suicide at 17. I feel compelled to tell the story; but it will be different. It is not my story but I know the pain of loss so my heart and soul will go into the retelling.
Rose, I hear you (and I love your voice). It is wonderful to be able to create tactile or immediately visible commemorations. An artist who's work is focused on transformative creation, California based Judy Shintani helps others create tactile memories.
Anastasia, You made me chuckle with your (or LitChat's) "creating grief in the life of fictional characters", thank you for the link. I missed that convo myself. Talking about grief in fiction, I just finished reading The Slap by Christos Tsiolkas.
Grief can lead to great or at least entertaining literature, as Rose Deniz discusses in her latest blog post Pop culture or high art.
Jocelyn,
So sorry to read you lost your mother at 17.
Your comment made me think more of the time immediately after my father's death. I was more into drawing than writing at the time, creating pen and ink drawings of gravestone engravings and Goth funeral bearers. I could not read for the life of me, but I did write some gruesome poems none of which had to do with my father's death, or so I thought. I didn't realize the graphic description of a dead calf might have been a metaphor...
What struck me after I published this particular post is that I did not mention the death of my mother (in 2002). While hers came after a long life, not mentioning her might call for another post, so I'll leave it at that.
Doreen, Good on you! as my Aussie friend Paul would say. To share with the world is no small feat, I know all about that and salute you for having come that far!
Stories about loss, about murder and suicide are important to share, for yourself and for all those others who may not be able to voice their grief, anger and despair. Sharing can bring solace. Good on you!
Thanks for introducing me to Judy Shintani, Judith! I like how she says "My art focuses on remembrance, connection, and storytelling." I can really relate to that.
@Jocelyn, I didn't realize we had mother loss in common. Don't know if you've read Motherless Daughters, but it was a really important book for me. I've since read Hope Edelman's recent book, Motherless Mothers, and that's helped tremendously as I raise my children.
@Rose You and Jocelyn having the loss of your mothers at an early age in common was on my mind, but I waited for you to mention that. Indeed Hope Edelman's book is great, for all of us I think. I imagine her book on raising children must be helpful. I foresee a book on growing old without having seen one's mother grow old, a shared experience of aging Holocaust survivors.
Just being made aware of the examples we lack, sends us looking for those of others. We're hardly ever totally alone in our experience (or lack there of).
xoxo
Judith
Post a Comment